Good enough: stop going round on a decision

Why looking for the perfect choice can leave you less happy with it, and four steps to decide and move on.

Some decisions keep coming back. Which flat, which job, which laptop, whether to say yes. You weigh it again, look for one more review, imagine each option once more, and end up where you started, only more tired.

Part of the problem is looking for the best possible choice. The economist Herbert Simon called the other way satisficing: choosing the first option that meets the standards you set. In a well-known 2002 study, the psychologist Barry Schwartz and colleagues found that people who always try to find the very best option often end up less happy with what they choose, and more troubled by what they did not, than people who settle for good enough.

Here are four steps to decide and move on. First, write down the two or three things that really matter, such as cost, distance or time. Second, set a deadline: I will decide by Friday at six. Third, ask what you would tell a friend in your place; people tend to reason more wisely about someone else’s problem than their own. Fourth, choose the option that is good enough on what matters, and stop looking.

Most decisions can be adjusted later, and very few are as final as they feel at midnight. A good choice made today usually beats a perfect one still being weighed next month.

If the same decision keeps coming back after you have made it, treat that as a loop rather than new information. Notice it, remind yourself that you have decided, and let it pass.

Goes with this article

Related

FinClamp: personal development, made playful. About · Contact · Privacy · Terms