Thinking or overthinking? How to tell
Useful thinking moves you forward; overthinking goes round. A simple test to tell them apart, and what to do when you are in a loop.
Thinking about a problem is useful. You look at what happened, weigh what you could do, and choose. Overthinking feels the same from the inside, but it goes round instead of forward: the same conversation replayed, the same what-if imagined, the same decision reopened, with nothing new each time.
Researchers who study this kind of repetitive thinking, such as Edward Watkins at the University of Exeter, have found that the helpful kind tends to be concrete. What exactly happened? What is one thing I could do next? The unhelpful kind tends to be abstract: why does this always happen to me, what does it say about me? Concrete questions have answers. Abstract ones can be asked for ever.
So here is a simple test. Ask yourself: in the last ten minutes, has my thinking given me anything new? A fact, a decision, a next step? If it has, keep going; you are working on it. If it has not, you are in a loop, and more thinking will not get you out. A change of approach will.
Get the thought out of your head and look at it. Write it in one sentence. Ask the concrete question: is there something I can do about this in the next day? If there is, choose one small step and when. If not, give it a time later, or notice that it is out of your hands and let it pass.
Loops often come with a body that is tense and breathing fast, so slow down there too: a few long breaths out can make the next decision easier. If overthinking fills most of your days or keeps you from sleeping, talk to a doctor or someone you trust.
Goes with this article
- Untangle a thought (Calm): Write it down, name the loop, decide one thing to do with it, and breathe. Parked thoughts come back at your worry time.
- Worry time (Calm lessons): Give worries a short, fixed time each day, and park them the rest of it.
- Notice it, name it, breathe (Calm lessons): For racing thoughts: name the feeling, find it in the body, breathe with it.
- Breath awareness (Meditate): Rest your attention on the breath, and come back each time it wanders.
Related
- Untangle a thought
- Worry time
- Notice it, name it, breathe
- Breath awareness
- How your fingers learn the keyboard
- Ship or sheep: the sounds that change a word
- Say it in thirty seconds
- Small talk without the panic
- Disagree with your boss, kindly
- Bring bad news early
- Look at the lens: presence on a video call
- Work with a weakness, one step at a time
- Build self-trust with small promises
- Turn a setback into a next step
- Use your strengths on purpose
- Set a kind boundary and keep it
- Let your values guide your choices
- Missing a day won’t break your habit
- When motivation is low, make the first step smaller
- Remember more of what you read
- Reaction time: what practice really changes
- Mental maths you’ll actually use
- Think in steps: what logic puzzles teach
- The spotlight is smaller than you think
- Why a little competition helps you practise
- Breathe out a little longer
- Box breathing: a steady square
- The 20-20-20 break for tired eyes
- Wind down for a calmer bedtime
- Name it to tame it
- Build a happier day without chasing perfect happiness
- Practise gratitude without pretending everything is fine
- Be patient with the person you are becoming
- Worry time: give your worries an appointment
- It’s just a thought: unhooking from a loop
- Good enough: stop going round on a decision
- When your mind races at night
- Read
FinClamp: personal development, made playful. About · Contact · Privacy · Terms