Disagree with your boss
“Can I offer another view?” Bring data and a proposal, then commit. Lesson 37 of 53: Speak up to seniors, stage 6 of Confidence.
Disagreeing is part of the job
- Good managers want to hear when you think they are wrong, before it is too late, as long as it is said well. Silence is not loyalty: a project that fails because nobody spoke up helps nobody. Disagree in private where you can, with data, and with a proposal.
- Can I offer a different view? (Asking permission to disagree)
Ask, show, propose, then commit
- Ask: “Can I offer a different view?” Show: the evidence, briefly — “The last two launches in December lost a third of their users.” Propose: “What if we launched in January and used December for a beta?” Then listen to their reasons; they may know something you do not.
- If they still decide against you, commit fully: “Understood. I’ll make December work.” This is called disagree and commit. You will be trusted with the next disagreement because you did not sulk through this one.
- The data from the last two launches points the other way. (Showing evidence)
- What if we tried it in January instead? (A proposal)
- Understood. I’ll make it work. (Commit)
- Open palms: Honest and inviting: “here is what I think”. The most useful gesture there is.
- Fingertips together: Thoughtful and confident: “I am considering this carefully.” Overdone, it can look smug.
- Tip: Disagree with the idea, never the person: “I see a risk in this plan,” not “You are wrong.”
Lines to have ready
- Can I offer a different view? (Asking to disagree)
- I see a risk in this plan. (The idea, not the person)
- What if we…? (Proposing)
- Understood. I’ll make it work. (Disagree and commit)
Your turn to speak
- Think of a decision at work, school or home you disagree with. Record yourself raising it in under a minute: ask to offer a view, give one piece of evidence, propose an alternative, and say how you will commit if they still decide the other way.
- I asked before disagreeing
- I gave evidence, not just an opinion
- I proposed an alternative
- I said I would commit if overruled
Watch your video back for
- Eye contact: on the camera, not the screen or the floor
- Posture: upright and still, shoulders down
- Hands: visible and open, moving with the words
- Face: it shows what you mean, and smiles where it should
Related
- Lesson 36: The lift and corridor moment
- Lesson 38: Bring bad news early
- The whole Confidence course
- Today’s dare
FinClamp: personal development, made playful. About · Contact · Privacy · Terms